| Platinum | Herbert Fisheries |
| Gold | Fish Market Jessinik and Chipstand |
| Silver | Georgian Bay Fish & Chips |
| Bronze | Silver Bullet |
| Top Pick | Chateau Guay Motel Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Chemmy's Fish & Chips |
| Top Pick | Eddies Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Jak's Diner |
| Top Pick | Miss Maple's Big Nickle Pickle |
| Top Pick | Silver Bullet 2.0 |