| Platinum | Cardino's Pizzeria |
| Gold | Dons Pizza Sudbury |
| Silver | Pizza Pazzaz |
| Bronze | Pizzeria Roma |
| Top Pick | Cortina Pizza |
| Top Pick | Cousin Vinny's Restaurant & Bar |
| Top Pick | Di Gusto Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Great Lakes Pizza Co |
| Top Pick | P&M's Kouzzina |
| Top Pick | Twiggs Coffee Roasters |